Mechanical vs Electrocapacitive vs Membrane Keyboards

When looking for a new keyboard, you might feel overwhelmed by the sheer number of options. Words like mechanical, membrane, and electrostatic capacity (electro-capacitive) are probably familiar to you. But what do these terms actually mean? Are they just marketing jargon?

These refer to "switch mechanisms (switch technology)," which affect the typing feel, durability, and comfort during long hours of use. The differences manifest in feedback, input stability, and long-term maintainability.

In this article, we will explain the three main types of keyboards commonly seen on the market (mechanical, membrane, electrostatic capacity) and clearly organize their differences. By the end, you should have a clear idea of which type suits you best and why you would choose it.

What is a Mechanical Keyboard?

A mechanical keyboard features individual mechanical switches under each key. When you press a key, the stem moves down, and metal contacts touch to register the input. The fact that each key has its own independent switch is what fundamentally sets mechanical keyboards apart from other types.

Because of the physical mechanism, the keystroke feedback is clear and predictable, with the tactile feel varying depending on the type of switch used.

• Linear: Smooth without any resistance
• Tactile: Provides a noticeable "bump" at the actuation point
• Clicky: Similar to tactile but with an audible click sound

What is a Membrane Keyboard?

The membrane keyboard is the most common type that many people first encounter. Instead of individual switches, it uses a **single rubber membrane** beneath dome-shaped rubber keys. When you press a key, the rubber dome collapses and pushes against the membrane to register input.

This design is lightweight and easier to produce at a lower cost, offering relatively quiet and easy-to-use functionality. However, the typing feel tends to be softer with less defined feedback.

What is an Electrostatic Capacity (Electro-Capacitive) Keyboard?

The electrostatic capacity (electro-capacitive) keyboard is one of the newer designs and is often considered a step above traditional membrane keyboards. Structurally, it is similar to membrane keyboards, butRubber dome and spring is used, butThere is no physical contact with metal contacts. Key input is detected by a change in capacitance on the PCB.

This 'non-contact detection' ensures high consistency in keystrokes and reduces long-term wear. The keystroke feel is soft and cushioned yet precise, avoiding the 'mushy sensation' common in typical membrane keyboards.

Mechanical vs Capacitive vs Membrane: Comparison

By now, you should have understood the mechanism and basics of each type. However, knowing just the structure isn't enough to make a choice. What's important is how it feels during daily use and how it changes over time.

With that in mind, we compared the three types based on elements directly related to typing experience, comfort, and long-term use.

---

Keystroke feel

Mechanicalis characterized by a firmer, more defined keystroke. Because it uses a physical switch with springs and metal contacts, the actuation point is clearly felt. Depending on the switch, there are variations like smooth, light bump, or strong bump. On the other hand, bottoming out can be hard, which might lead to fatigue during long typing sessions.

Membraneis softer with less structural feedback. Input often requires fully collapsing the rubber dome, resulting in frequent bottoming out, which may feel sluggish despite the cushioning. Over time, the elasticity of the dome decreases, further reducing keystroke consistency.

Capacitiveoffers the softest and least fatiguing keystroke feel among the three. This is due to its switch structure and the method of actuation detection.

Noise

The volume is influenced by the internal structure of the key.

• Mechanicalis the loudest, and even apart from clicky sounds, you may hear the stem hitting the housing or bottoming out. The volume is generally around 60-70dB approximately.
• Membranehas rubber domes that absorb impact, making it relatively quiet, but the sound quality is dull, and unevenness can occur as the dome deteriorates. The volume is generally around 40-50dB approximately.
• Capacitiveuses non-contact mechanisms with a lighter touch and is the quietest of the three. NIZ's capacitive keyboards (e.g., L84) are known for having about 35dB a low keypress noise of

Operation (Input) Stability

Operational stability refers to how consistently keys input at the 'same position and feel' (and whether this consistency is maintained over time).

• Mechanicalrelies on metal contacts and leaf springs, so differences between keys may arise due to manufacturing tolerances, wear, and oxidation. Over time, issues like chattering may occur. High-quality switches can mitigate this, but some degree of variation is hard to avoid due to design limitations.
• Membraneis the most prone to instability. Rubber domes have slight variations in shape and hardness, and their deterioration is not uniform. As they age, the feel and actuation points of each key become inconsistent.
• Capacitivedetects changes in capacitance electronically, so there’s no physical contact point, and wear has minimal effect. As long as the dome and spring retain their shape, the actuation point tends to remain stable.

Durability

• Mechanicaltypically lasts around 10-15 years under normal use. While switches are often designed to withstand tens of millions of keystrokes, wear can still occur over time due to the presence of metal contacts and moving parts.
• Membranehas the shortest lifespan, as the elasticity of the rubber dome diminishes with repeated compression. In many cases, after about 3-5 years the feel becomes unstable or input issues start to occur.
• Capacitiveis designed for longevity. Since there’s no physical contact, metal friction does not occur. NIZ claims that its capacitive switches can withstand 100 million keystrokes up to

Typing Fatigue

Typing fatigue varies from person to person. Some people prefer strong feedback, while others may find it tiring.

• When it comes to typing alone,Mechanicaltends to be the most tiring. The distinct actuation and harder bottoming can strain the fingers over extended periods.
• Membraneis soft, but the keys are easier to press down deeply, often resulting in bottoming out almost every time. Even if it feels light, repeated impacts can lead to fatigue.
• Capacitivegenerally tends to be the least fatiguing. In addition to a softer cushioning, stable actuation is achieved more easily, reducing the need to press keys all the way down, thus minimizing finger impact.

Customizability

• Membraneoffers almost no customizability. Since the switches are integrated into a single membrane, changing the key feel would require replacing the entire keyboard.
• Mechanicaloffers the highest level of customizability. A variety of switches can be chosen, keycap replacement is easy, and some models even allow switch swapping without soldering.
• Capacitivetypically falls somewhere in between. Physical customization is often limited, but NIZ keyboards are an exception, offering software-level customization such as key remapping, macros, shortcuts, andCherry MX-compatible keycapssupport, allowing adjustments to appearance and feel while maintaining the advantages of capacitive technology.

Which keyboard should you choose?

By now, you should have a clear understanding of the differences between mechanical, membrane, and capacitive keyboards. The reason all three types remain popular is simple: each suits different users and purposes. The optimal choice depends on what you prioritize in your daily use.

MechanicalRecommended for people who:

• Prefer strong feedback (tactile sensation) like in gaming
• Enjoy customizing or experimenting with switch types and modifications

MembraneRecommended for people who:

• Looking for a budget-friendly option
• Desire quietness for casual use
• Need a lightweight keyboard for basic typing

CapacitiveRecommended for people who:

• Do long hours of typing and prioritize comfort
• Want quietness but do not want to compromise on precision

If capacitive seems to match your needs, it’s worth checking out NIZ’s keyboard collection and user reviews.